Etsy vs Shopify in 2026: Fees, SEO, AI Visibility and Which to Choose

Quick quiz

Where should your online shop find its next customers?

Question 1 of 425%

When do you need sales?

This monthIn 3 to 6 months, but for the long termSome now, more later

Most comparisons of Etsy vs Shopify stop at fees and ease of use. This guide adds what decides your traffic for the next five years: who controls the pages Google indexes, which technical SEO settings you can change, who owns the customer relationship, and what ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity can cite when a shopper asks for a recommendation. Every Etsy fee below comes from the official Etsy Fees & Payments Policy (checked October 2026), and every Shopify price from Shopify's own pricing page.

What is the difference between Etsy and Shopify?

Etsy is a marketplace: buyers come to etsy.com, search, compare dozens of shops on one results page and pay through Etsy. Your shop is a section of someone else's website, with Etsy's layout, Etsy's checkout and Etsy's rules. Shopify is a store builder: it hosts your own website on your own domain, with your theme, your checkout and your customer list, but nobody visits it unless you send them there.

That single difference explains everything else. On Etsy you rent access to existing demand and pay for it on every order. On Shopify you pay a flat fee for the infrastructure, then invest in traffic that becomes an asset you keep. The scale of that existing demand is real: Etsy's shareholder letter for the third quarter of 2026, filed with the US Securities and Exchange Commission, reports approximately 88 million active buyers over twelve months and $2.6 billion of marketplace sales in the quarter, up 8.8% year over year. A Shopify store starts with none of those buyers.

How do Etsy and Shopify compare at a glance?

The table below sums up the comparison for a US seller. Each line is detailed in its own section further down.

How much does it cost to sell on Etsy?

Etsy has no monthly subscription but charges on every listing and every sale. For a seller with a US bank account, the fees in force in October 2026 are the following.

• Listing fee: $0.20 per item, valid four months, charged again on renewal and after each sale of a multi-quantity listing.
• Transaction fee: 6.5% of the displayed price plus shipping and gift wrapping (US sellers do not pay it on sales tax).
• Payment processing: 3% + $0.25 per order for a US bank account, assessed on the total including shipping and tax. Sellers in most euro countries pay 4% + 0.30 EUR, and UK sellers 4% + 0.20 GBP, according to the Etsy Payments Policy.
• Offsite Ads: 15% of orders attributed to Etsy's ads on external sites (social networks, search engines) within 30 days of a click. Once a shop passes $10,000 in sales over 365 days, the rate drops to 12% but participation becomes mandatory for the life of the shop. The fee never exceeds $100 per order.
• Currency conversion: 2.5% when you list in a currency other than your payment account currency.
• Depending on the country: a one-time set-up fee when you open the shop, and a Regulatory Operating fee (a fixed percentage per order).
• Optional: Etsy Plus at $10 per month, and Pattern (a standalone website built by Etsy) at $15 per month after a 30-day trial.

Add those lines up and a typical US order costs about 9.5% plus $0.45 in fees before any advertising. On an order that came from Offsite Ads, the total climbs to roughly 25%, which is why the share of Offsite Ads sales in your Etsy stats matters more than the headline rate.

How much does Shopify cost?

Shopify charges a monthly subscription and no listing fee, with a lower card rate on higher plans. The prices below are Shopify's US list prices; the Shopify pricing page displays the local currency of each visitor, and the euro column shows what it displayed from Europe (checked October 2026).

New stores get a 3-day trial, then $1 per month for the first three months on Basic, Grow and Advanced. In the US, the online card rate with Shopify Payments is 2.9% + 30¢ on Basic, 2.7% + 30¢ on Grow, 2.5% + 30¢ on Advanced and 2.25% + 30¢ on Plus. Shopify's pricing page also lists selling in AI chats as included on every plan, and an Agentic plan at $0 per month that only charges a fee per sale made through AI channels. Budget for a paid theme (often a one-time purchase) and apps if you need them.

Which is cheaper for your sales volume?

For a few orders a month, Etsy is cheaper because it has no subscription. Shopify becomes cheaper once the difference in per-order fees covers its monthly price. Take one $40 order with $5 shipping (a $45 total, before sales tax) for a US seller.

The gap is about $3.12 per order. Shopify's $39 monthly fee is covered after roughly 13 orders a month of this size (about $585 in sales), or 10 orders on yearly billing. The table below extends the calculation to three volumes, without Offsite Ads.

This comparison only counts platform fees. On Shopify, the real extra cost is the traffic you must bring yourself: content, email, social media or ads. On Etsy, the real extra cost is Offsite Ads and the 12% that becomes mandatory above $10,000 in yearly sales.

How much does Etsy take from a $100 sale?

On a $100 order (item and shipping) from a US seller, Etsy keeps about $9.95: $0.20 listing fee, $6.50 transaction fee and $3.25 payment processing (3% + $0.25). If the buyer clicked an Offsite Ad in the previous 30 days, add $15 (or $12 for larger shops), for a total of $24.95. The same $100 order on Shopify Basic costs about $3.20 in card fees with Shopify Payments, before the share of the monthly subscription.

Who owns the customer, the brand and the data?

On Etsy, the buyer is an Etsy customer first. You receive what you need to ship the order, but you cannot freely add buyers to a mailing list, retarget them or move them to another site: the fee policy states that any action to move a transaction off the Etsy platform is strictly prohibited. Your shop can also be suspended under Etsy's policies, and your listings appear next to similar items from other shops on the same page.

On Shopify, the customer list, the email consent, the analytics and the domain belong to you. That is what makes repeat sales and a recognizable brand possible, and it matters for search too: a domain you own accumulates links, reviews and mentions that keep working for you, while the authority built by an Etsy shop mostly strengthens etsy.com. If you ever sell the business, a domain with rankings and a customer list is a transferable asset; an Etsy shop is much harder to transfer.

Which platform is better for SEO: Etsy or Shopify?

Shopify gives you far more SEO control; Etsy gives you the authority of etsy.com but very few settings. Etsy listings do appear on Google under the etsy.com domain. Within Etsy, ranking depends on how well titles, tags and attributes match the query, on listing quality and on shop performance, as detailed in our guide to Etsy SEO. Shopify gives you the levers that Google describes in its SEO best practices for ecommerce sites: URL structure, structured data, crawlable category pages.

The limits on Etsy are structural: no real blog, no 301 redirects, no control over the XML sitemap, and a visitor who lands on your listing from Google sees links to competing shops. On Shopify, you can add schema markup, write collection texts, publish buying guides and fix technical issues with the best Shopify SEO apps. The catch: a new domain starts with no authority, so Shopify SEO is a long-term investment of several months before the store ranks on competitive queries.

Product pages remain the core on both platforms: clear titles, real photos, unique descriptions and answers to buyers' questions. The checklist of an ecommerce product page that ranks applies to Etsy listings and Shopify products alike.

Which one do ChatGPT and other AI assistants recommend?

Both platforms can now put a product in front of a shopper who asks an AI assistant. On September 29, 2025, OpenAI launched Instant Checkout in ChatGPT, starting with US Etsy sellers and announcing over a million Shopify merchants next. OpenAI said at the time that more than 700 million people use ChatGPT each week, and that product results are organic and unsponsored, ranked on relevance to the user. Etsy's Chief Product and Technology Officer, Rafe Colburn, summed up the marketplace's view in the same announcement: "ChatGPT helps us meet buyers where they are."

"Bringing Shopify merchants into ChatGPT lets indie brands to household names reach customers in entirely new ways, meeting high-intent shoppers in relevant conversations."

Vanessa Lee, VP of Product, Shopify, OpenAI announcement

The difference lies in what an AI can cite to justify a recommendation. An Etsy listing is one product card among millions on a domain Etsy controls. A Shopify store can publish what generative answers quote: buying guides, comparison pages, size and material explanations, and FAQs with direct answers. Our Shopify AI citation study looks at which store pages the AIs reference, and our overview of AI in ecommerce covers the new AI shopping channel.

What can you sell on Etsy versus Shopify?

Etsy only accepts handmade items, items you designed, vintage items (at least 20 years old) and craft supplies. Print on demand is allowed when you create the design yourself and disclose your production partner. Resale of goods made by others, dropshipping of generic products and most private-label catalogues do not belong on Etsy and can get a shop suspended.

Shopify accepts almost any legal product: physical goods, digital downloads, services, subscriptions, wholesale and dropshipping. That flexibility is the main reason growing brands move: once the catalogue mixes handmade pieces with sourced products, only an independent store can hold everything. Our comparison of the best ecommerce platforms for SEO covers the other options when Shopify is not the right fit.

Can you sell on Etsy and Shopify at the same time?

Yes, and many sellers do: Etsy for discovery, Shopify for the brand and repeat buyers. Apps from the Shopify App Store sync products, inventory and orders between the two, so a sale on one channel updates stock on the other. Etsy remains a separate marketplace with its own rules: you cannot redirect Etsy buyers to your store during a transaction, but your packaging, your brand name and your social accounts can make your own site known.

Moving from Etsy to Shopify has two limits to plan for. Your Etsy reviews do not transfer automatically (you can import them into a reviews app, with Etsy's display rules in mind), and since Etsy offers no redirects, the rankings of your Etsy listings stay on etsy.com. The same logic applies to other marketplaces, as our guide to Amazon SEO shows: the marketplace keeps the authority, your domain keeps what you build on it.

Should you choose Etsy or Shopify? The verdict by profile

The right choice depends on your audience, your catalogue and how long you plan to build. The table gives the verdict for the most common seller profiles.

How do you bring organic traffic to a Shopify store?

The weak point of Shopify is the empty store on day one. The durable fix is content that ranks and gets cited: collection pages with useful text, product pages that answer real questions, and articles that target what your buyers search on Google and ask the AIs. Our Shopify SEO and GEO page lists the settings to check first.

Sorank, our product, is an SEO and GEO software that does this work in autopilot: it finds the keywords, writes and publishes optimized articles with the blog article generator, connects to Shopify in minutes and tracks whether ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini mention your store with AI mention tracking. Plans start at $49 per month billed yearly, with a 3-day free trial; see pricing. First effects on Google usually appear within 2 to 4 months.

What is the bottom line on Etsy vs Shopify?

Etsy is the cheapest way to find out whether strangers will buy your product: no subscription, millions of buyers, fees of about 10% per order. Shopify is the way to build a business that owns its customers, its domain and its search visibility, and it costs less per order from about 13 orders a month. Start on Etsy to validate, move to Shopify to grow, and keep both while Etsy still brings new buyers. Whatever you choose in 2026, the traffic you build on your own domain is the only part that compounds.