Preferences

Privacy is important to us, so you have the option of disabling certain types of storage that may not be necessary for the basic functioning of the website. Blocking categories may impact your experience on the website. More information (Cookie Policy)

Ahrefs vs Semrush vs SpyFu: Which One to Choose and How to Test Them

Compare Ahrefs, Semrush and SpyFu on keywords, backlinks and plan limits, then run a one-week test on your own keywords to pick the right one.

Published on
21/11/2026
Updated on
21/11/2026
Reading time
13 min
Ahrefs vs Semrush vs SpyFu: Which One to Choose and How to Test Them

Tools

On this page

In short

Ahrefs, Semrush and SpyFu are paid SEO platforms that show the keywords, backlinks and ads behind any domain, including your competitors'. They overlap on keyword research, but each one has its own database and its own strength. In most reviews, Ahrefs leads on backlinks, Semrush on all-in-one work, and SpyFu on paid search and a lower entry price.

Want to go further? Ask

Quick quiz

Which kind of SEO tool is right for you?

Question 1 of 425%
How well do you know SEO?

What each tool is built for

Each tool answers the same question, "what is working for my competitors?", from a different angle. Ahrefs is built around its link index and site audits. Semrush is built as one toolkit that also covers content, local SEO and social media. SpyFu focuses on competitor and paid search research.

Those focuses matter more than the feature lists, which look alike on every pricing page. Use the table below to see where each tool is strongest before you open a trial.

ToolStrongest forKeyword researchBacklinksFree access
AhrefsBacklink research and site auditsKeyword Explorer with volume, difficulty and SERP viewsLarge link index, a core part of the productA free plan is listed on its pricing page
SemrushAll-in-one work across SEO, content and localKeyword Overview with difficulty scores and related termsBacklink analytics, audits and link-building toolsFree plan with daily report limits (see section 8)
SpyFuCompetitor and paid search researchKeyword data with a strong paid search focusNarrower backlink analysis than the two others in most reviewsFree views on the site, with limits that change often

The keyword side in practice

All three give you a search volume, a difficulty score and the pages that rank for a term. The difficulty score is an estimate, not a probability that you will rank, which is why keyword difficulty needs a check in the results before you write. If you only read one number, you will pick the wrong keyword more often than you think.

Ahrefs is the usual first pick when the job is to see who links to a rival and why. Semrush covers the same ground with more tools around it, such as link building and audit reports. SpyFu shows fewer backlink details, so it works better as a second opinion than as the only source for link work.

SpyFu is built to show which keywords a domain buys on Google Ads and how long it has bought them. That is useful when you plan a paid campaign or a content gap, because a keyword that rivals pay for is often a keyword that converts. Semrush and Ahrefs also show paid data, but most reviews name SpyFu first for it.

Why the same keyword gets three different numbers

Each tool estimates search volume and difficulty from its own data, so the same keyword can show three different volumes and three different difficulty scores. None of them is the search volume Google reports, and none of them is wrong by default. The gap is the reason to test the tools, not to trust one of them.

The difference comes from three sources: each tool's crawler and link index, its own clickstream or panel data, and its own model for turning that data into a volume. Two tools can agree on the top keyword and still disagree on the long tail, where the estimates are weakest. Read the numbers as ranking signals, not as traffic forecasts.

Trusting one tool or cross-checking

One tool only
  • A single estimate with no baseline
  • Easy to over-trust a score
Two tools and Google
  • Outliers show up fast
  • You see which estimate holds in the results

A useful rule: when two tools disagree by a wide margin on a keyword, check the top ten results in Google before you decide. The page types you see there tell you more than either number. A list of forums and product pages means the keyword is easier than a list of large brands, whatever the score says.

Three blue data towers linked to a central magnifying glass on a white background
Three sources of SEO data compared side by side before a decision.

Three ways to get competitor keywords, and when each one is enough

You can pull competitor keywords in three ways: a tool report, a manual reading of the results, or a weekly watch on what rivals publish. Each one answers a different question, and the best setup uses at least two of them. Most teams start with the tool report and skip the other two, which is where they miss the newest topics.

Method 1: the tool report

Principle: you enter a rival domain and export the keywords it ranks for. Use it when you need a full list fast. Advantages: it is quick, it gives volume and difficulty in one file, and it works for any domain. Limits: it shows the past, so a page that ranked last year may already be gone, and each tool's list will differ.

Example: enter a rival blog, export the organic keywords, sort by estimated traffic, then remove the brand name and the terms that only match its product names. The list left over is a first set of topic ideas, not a plan.

Method 2: manual reading of the results page

Principle: you search your seed keyword in a private window and read the top ten results, with attention to who ranks and what kind of page it is. Use it when you need intent and format, for example whether Google wants a comparison table, a tool or a guide. Advantages: it is free and it shows what Google shows today. Limits: it is slow and gives you no volume.

Example: for "keyword tool comparison", note whether the top results are review sites, vendor pages or forums. If three of the top five are vendor pages, a neutral guide with a clear method has a real gap to fill.

Method 3: monitoring what rivals publish

Principle: you track the new pages of a fixed list of rivals each week and read the keywords behind them. Use it when you want the topics before they rank. Advantages: it catches what rivals start, not just what they already rank for. Limits: it only covers the rivals you watch, and it needs a routine, or it fades after a month.

MethodQuestion it answersBest whenMain limit
Tool reportWhat does this rival rank for?You need a full list todayIt shows the past and differs by tool
Manual reading of resultsWhat kind of page wins this query?You are choosing format and intentSlow, with no volume data
Weekly monitoringWhat are rivals publishing now?You want topics before they rankOnly covers the rivals you add

Which tool fits which job

Pick the tool by the job you do most often, not by the length of the feature list. Treat the table below as a starting point, then test your own keywords as described in section 6. The right tool for a solo writer is rarely the right one for an agency with twenty client sites.

JobStart withWhy
Backlinks to a rivalAhrefsIts link index is the common reference in reviews, so check the same links in a second tool
Keyword research for a new siteSemrush or AhrefsBoth have large databases, filters for intent and related term lists
Paid search and ad keywordsSpyFuIts paid data is the focus of the product
Several client sites under one loginSemrushIts higher plans include more projects

If you want a wider list of options before you compare these three, read our roundup of the 8 best keyword research tools. It puts them next to tools that do one job well and cost less.

Price and plan limits: compare the cost per tracked keyword

The monthly price tells you little on its own. Compare what each plan includes, such as tracked keywords, projects, crawl credits and seats, then divide the price by the number you need. Ahrefs lists its Lite plan at 119 euros a month, excluding tax, with 750 tracked keywords, 5 non-verified projects and 100000 crawl credits, according to its Ahrefs pricing page, checked November 21, 2026.

Ahrefs pricing page listing its Lite, Standard and Advanced plans with monthly prices and tracked keyword limits
Source: Ahrefs pricing page

Prices on that page are shown in euros and change by region, so read the figures you see when you open it. Crawl credits matter when you audit a large site, because a single full crawl can use a big share of a monthly allowance. Check the crawl limit before you schedule a recurring audit.

Here is the calculation on the three Ahrefs plans, using the prices above:

cost per tracked keyword = monthly price / tracked keywords

Lite:      119 / 750   = 0.16 per keyword
Standard:  229 / 2000  = 0.11 per keyword
Advanced:  419 / 5000  = 0.08 per keyword

The number helps you compare plans inside one tool. Do not use it to compare tools directly, because a tracked keyword in one product may refresh less often than in another. For Semrush, the Semrush pricing page sets its plans by daily tracked keywords, projects and daily AI prompts, so run the same calculation on the plan you would buy.

A one-week test on your own keyword list

Run the same list through each tool for one week, then check the results against what Google shows. This is the test that most buyers skip, and it is the only one that tells you which tool matches your market. You need no budget beyond the trials and a spreadsheet.

Tip

Build the seed list with the free Keyword Research and Suggestions Tool, then paste the same terms into each trial. That way the test starts from one list, not three.

The one-week test in five steps

  1. Build the seed listUse 20 to 30 terms you want to rank for, with a few long-tail variants.
  2. Export from each toolSave volume, difficulty and the top ten pages for every term in one sheet per tool.
  3. Check the results by handSearch the five highest-volume terms in a private window and note the page types.
  4. Score the estimatesFor each tool, count how many "easy" terms actually show weak pages in the results.
  5. Keep the tool that matchesChoose the one whose difficulty scores line up with the results most often.

Read the difficulty score with care. Keyword difficulty is a relative estimate, so a score of 30 in one tool can sit next to a score of 40 in another for the same page. Compare the ranking of your terms inside each tool, not the raw numbers across tools.

For the full method behind a list like this, our guide to keyword gap analysis shows how to compare your terms with a rival's and sort the gaps by value.

Compare backlinks by the number of referring domains, their relevance to your topic and whether the link was earned. A high count of links from unrelated sites adds little, and a short list from strong, relevant sites often does more. Ahrefs is the usual pick for this work, but any tool can list links that Google does not count.

Metrics such as Domain Rating summarize a site's link profile in one number. Treat them as a sorting tool, then open the linking pages and read them. A link from a page that answers the same question as yours is worth more than a link from a directory with a high score.

The line between a healthy link and a risky one is set by Google. Its spam policies, checked November 21, 2026, define link spam as "the practice of creating links to or from a site primarily for the purpose of manipulating search rankings", and list "buying or selling links for ranking purposes" among the examples.

Google Search Central spam policies page with its section on link spam and buying links
Source: Google Search Central, spam policies

Earned links or bought links

Earned
  • A page links because it answers a question well
  • The link fits the topic of the page
  • The site is one you would link to yourself
Bought or traded
  • Paid placement with a link that passes ranking credit
  • Mass link exchanges with no topic fit

A rival's link list is a starting point for outreach, not a shopping list. Start with how to find your competitors' backlinks and win them, and keep the backlink exchange rules in mind before you ask anyone to link to you. Most of the risk in link work hides in reciprocal deals.

Free plans and what they really cover

Free plans are enough to check a site or a few keywords, but none of them covers a full competitor study. Semrush's free plan is the most explicit about its limits on its pricing page, which makes it the easiest to plan around. Read each free plan's limits before you build a process on it.

OptionWhat is freeLimit listed
AhrefsA free plan on its pricing pageNo report limits shown on that page, so check the plan details
SemrushA free plan with daily reports10 reports per day and one demo project, as listed on its pricing page
SorankFree tools for keyword suggestions and backlink checksLimits are shown on each tool page, such as the backlink checker
Semrush pricing page comparing plans by tracked keywords, projects and daily queries, with a free plan
Source: Semrush pricing page

Use free access for the checks that do not need a full history, such as a quick view of a rival's top pages. Keep the paid trial for the work that needs exports, history and recurring reports. Check SpyFu's free views on its site before you plan around them, because those limits change often.

Common mistakes when comparing the three

Most bad tool choices come from four mistakes: judging by the feature list, trusting one number, counting links without checking their quality and buying a plan before the test. Each one is easy to spot once you know what to look for, and each one has a fix you can apply in an afternoon.

Before and after a tool decision

Before
  • Pick the tool with the longest feature list
  • Trust the first volume number you see
After
  • Test the same list in two tools
  • Check the top results in Google before you write

Mistake 1: judging by the feature list

What it is: choosing a tool because it has more reports, more filters or more data types. How to spot it: you cannot name the three reports you will use each week. How to fix it: write down the two or three jobs you do most often, then test only the tools that do those jobs well. A long feature list is a cost, because you pay for the modules you never open.

Mistake 2: trusting one number

What it is: writing a page for a keyword because one tool shows a high volume and a low difficulty. How to spot it: the page you planned looks like the weakest result on the first page, or the volume does not match the traffic in your own analytics after a month. How to fix it: compare the same term in two tools, check the top ten results by hand, and write only when the page types leave room for yours.

What it is: measuring link building by the number of links on a report. How to spot it: the link list includes directories, widgets or sites with no real audience, and the count rises fast in a month. How to fix it: sort by relevance, open the linking pages, and drop any link that exists only to pass ranking credit. Google's spam policy describes the same pattern as a risk, so a weak link can cost more than it brings.

Mistake 4: buying a plan before the test

What it is: committing to a year before you have checked the data on your own keywords. How to spot it: you cannot say which keyword the tool got wrong. How to fix it: run the one-week test, then buy the cheapest plan that covers the export you need. Our Semrush review goes through its plans and their limits in more detail, which helps you decide whether the plan you are looking at fits your volume.

Where Sorank fits and what to do this week

Choose a tool that matches your main job, test it on your own keywords, then keep watching rivals every week. Sorank is an SEO and GEO platform that runs on autopilot, and it covers the watching part, so the work does not stop after the first export.

The SEO Spy Tool follows up to five competitors. Each week, it reads what they publish and adds the keywords behind their new pages to your content calendar, which is method 3 from section 3 without a manual setup. You still decide which topics to write, but you start from a list that is already sorted.

Your checklist for this week

  • Write a seed list of 20 to 30 keywords
  • Export the same list from two tools
  • Check the top ten results for your five best terms
  • Read the crawl and link limits on the plan you want
  • Choose the tool whose estimates match the results

If you do one thing today, export the same list from two tools and check the top results yourself. The tool that matches what you see in Google is the right one for your market, whatever the feature list says.

Frequently asked questions

Is Ahrefs better than Semrush or SpyFu?

Not in every case. Ahrefs is usually the first choice for backlink research, Semrush for an all-in-one workflow, and SpyFu for paid search on a smaller budget. The only reliable answer comes from running the same keyword list through each tool.

Are the keyword numbers from SpyFu, Ahrefs and Semrush accurate?

They are estimates from each tool's own database, so they differ from one tool to another and from Google's own tools. Use them to rank keywords against each other, then check the top candidates in Google before you write.

Can I compare the three tools with only their free plans?

You can run basic checks for free, but free plans cap reports and tracked keywords. Semrush's free plan lists 10 reports per day, which covers a few checks but not a full competitor study.

Get your content plan for 30 days for free

We analyse your competitors, your website and your AI visibility to create a tailored content plan for free.

Our free SEO tools

See all our free tools

Get your content plan for 30 days for free

We analyse your competitors, your website and your AI visibility to create a tailored content plan for free.

Man with dark hair and beard wearing a light brown shirt speaks in front of a microphone on a podcast or recording setup.Portrait of a man with short dark hair wearing a white shirt and dark jacket, looking directly at the camera with a neutral expression.Man with short dark hair, beard, and clear glasses wearing a black t-shirt with a white circular logo, standing in front of a stone wall.Celio fabianoSmiling young woman with long brown hair wearing a red top and necklace, outdoors in a tree-filled background.Profile photo of Xavier Breull, Sorank customer
Google
Solid yellow five-pointed star icon on transparent background.Solid yellow five-pointed star icon on transparent background.Solid yellow five-pointed star icon on transparent background.Solid yellow five-pointed star icon on transparent background.Solid yellow five-pointed star icon on transparent background.
5/5
+5,000
users

Testimonials from ambitious founders

0 to 10000 visitors in 5 months

Celio Fabianomonrobotlavevitre.frGoogleE-commerce

0 to 5000 visits in 8 months

Thibault BMsorank.comGoogleSoftware

0 to 1104 clicks in 4 months

Dominiqueflight-sensations-idf.comGoogleLeisure and aviation

0 to 163 clicks in 6 months

Coworking Pariscoworking-paris.frGoogleOffice broker

x92 clicks in 7 months

Guide Zanzibarguidezanzibar.comGoogleTravel